Let's Make Something Sweet

Place an Order

Choose what you'd like to order below.

Ordering is open

Weekly preorders open Sunday–Wednesday (or until sold out). Pickup the following week — details confirmed by email.

Middletown, DE

Sundays · 1:00 PM – 4:00 PM

Artisan Exchange, West Chester, PA

Saturdays · 1:00 PM – 2:30 PM

Tres Leches Cakes Weekly Presale

Our tres leches is handmade, soaked in three milks, and topped with whipped cream in your choice of tropical Caribbean flavor. Every slice is a little taste of home.

Classic
Classic

Traditional tres leches soaked in three milks with whipped cream topped with whipped cream, a dusting of cinnamon, and a cherry. The original, done right.

$8.00

Guava
Tropical

Tropical guava-infused tres leches topped with whipped cream and a drizzle of guava sauce. Sweet, fruity, and full of culture.

$8.00

Coffee
Espresso

Espresso-soaked tres leches topped topped with whipped cream and a dusting of cinnamon espresso. Dessert and caffeine. You’re welcome.

$8.00

Passion Fruit
Tropical

Passion fruit–soaked tres leches topped with whipped cream and a bright passion fruit drizzle. Tangy, sunny, and tropical.

$8.00

Cinnamon Rolls Weekly Presale

Four Latin-inspired flavors made fresh each week.

El Clásico
Classic

A classic cinnamon roll with cream cheese icing.

$8.00

La Dominicana
Guava

Guava-filled cinnamon roll topped with guava cream cheese icing.

$8.00

Café con Leche
Espresso

Espresso-infused cinnamon roll topped with creamy coffee cream cheese frosting.

$8.00

Dulce
Dulce de Leche Sea Salt

Dulce de leche cinnamon roll finished with dulce icing and a touch of sea salt.

$8.00

Sugar Cookie Preset Designs Weekly Presale

Monthly featured cookies available through our weekly presale — no custom order needed. Perfect for last-minute gifting or a little treat for yourself.

Each cookie comes heat sealed for freshness. Depending on the month and season, upgraded gift packaging may be available — think curated sets and ready-to-gift boxes. Browse what's available each week and order before we sell out!

Classic
Preset Design

Beautiful decorated sugar cookie, ready to enjoy.

$7.00 each

Gift Ready
Gift Tag Packaged

Same great cookie with a personalized gift tag and premium packaging.

$8.00 each

Payment processed securely via Square

Fill in your details below, then choose your items and complete payment on the next step. Pickup details will be confirmed by email no later than Wednesday.

Contact Information
Pickup
Before you submit — please review
  1. 1Minimum order: 2 dozen. Exception: "My Favorite Things" set (1-dozen min).
  2. 2Lead time: 2–4 weeks. Rush orders within 7 days incur a 25% surcharge.
  3. 3Pickup & Shipping. Pickup available in Middletown, DE and West Chester, PA. Sugar cookies can also be shipped anywhere within the US. Shipping and handling fees apply.
  4. 4Deposit: 50% non-refundable deposit due within 48 hours of invoice.
  5. 5Balance: Remaining 50% due one month before pickup.
  6. 6Changes: Theme/quantity changes accepted within 3 days of deposit only.
  7. 7Cancellations: Non-refundable. Rescheduling available.
  8. 8Unpaid invoices are auto-cancelled after 48 hours.

Pricing Reference

Custom cookies add an extra special touch to the moments that become memories that last a lifetime. Each order is designed, baked, and hand decorated personally for you and your loved ones.

Pricing starts at $78/dozen and varies based on design complexity and color palette. A 2-dozen minimum applies to all tiers, with the exception of the “My Favorite Things” set which has a 1-dozen minimum. All cookies are vanilla sugar cookies with royal icing, 3–4 inches in size, and individually heat sealed for freshness. Cookie flavor upgrades are available — just note your preference on the order form.

Classic Set
$78+/doz

Includes up to 4 designs with up to 3 colors (not including white). Clean, beautifully decorated cookies that are anything but basic — perfect for everyday celebrations and last-minute gifting.

Signature Set
$84+/doz

Includes up to 6 designs with up to 5 colors (not including white). This tier is perfect for orders featuring complex elements like 3D florals, metallic accents (gold, silver, or rose gold), lettering, or multi-layer icing work.

Showstopper
$96+/doz

Includes up to 8 designs with up to 6 colors (not including white). This tier is reserved for the most intricate work — think elaborate 3D florals, metallic accents, hand painted details, and highly detailed decorating that makes every cookie a centerpiece.

My Favorite Things
$108+/doz

Looking for a truly thoughtful gift? This set is designed to celebrate someone special in the most personal way. Each set includes 12 cookies, every single one uniquely decorated to reflect that person’s interests, hobbies, and favorite things. Comes beautifully packaged with ribbon, bows, or a custom tag — completely gift-ready. Share as many details as possible about the 12 favorite things you’d like represented. The more you tell us, the more personal your set will be!

Character Cookies
$8–$10 each

A premium add-on to any cookie set. Each cookie features one intricately hand-decorated character design, priced individually due to the detailed artistry and time required. Available as an add-on only — not sold as a standalone order.

View full pricing details →